Apologetics

Patristic theology, and traditional teachings of Orthodoxy from the Church fathers of apostolic times to the present. All forum Rules apply. No polemics. No heated discussions. No name-calling.


Evfimy

Post by Evfimy »

The problem Johanna is that the Orthodox aren't doing anything today to confront the attacks of the faith by our contemporary culture. They're too busy fighting among themselves as to who is and who is not Orthodox -- church politics.

It is evangelical and protestants scholars and theologians who are on the forefront in combating our culture and the ungodly teachings of the world.

The identity of Christ is under attack today by Gnostics, Mason's Jews and atheists. Are you even aware of this?

The protestants and evangelical scholars have pulverized their arguments.

You haven't even read the books I listed and you draw conclusions prior to examination.

I was selective in my bibliograohy. Nothing they say contradicts what we Orthodox hold to be true: God exists, Jesus is God, Jesus rose from the dead in His own body.

Even a broken clock is right twice a day. We should be thankful God is using them.

The truths in heterodoxy is the Orthodoxy they have retained. They are ultimately our truths.

And I know from experience in debating atheists and people of other religions, that the material in the books I listed is irrefutable.

And the material in those books come from some of the worlds greatest scholars and experts.

User avatar
joasia
Protoposter
Posts: 1858
Joined: Tue 29 June 2004 7:19 pm
Jurisdiction: RTOC
Location: Montreal

Post by joasia »

The problem Johanna is that the Orthodox aren't doing anything today to confront the attacks of the faith by our contemporary culture.

Really? Nobody? I disagree. Conversions to Orthodoxy happen everyday. My day was August 15th, 1993. I baptised my god-daughter who converted a few years ago(with her younger daughter) and now her older daughter has become a catechumen. They were protestants. Tomorrow, I’m meeting with a young woman, who I met at work, last year and shared some Orthdox materials (The Philokalia - which she loved and other materials) to talk about Orthodoxy. Apparently, I say things to people that make them want to know more about Orthodoxy. Of course, there are hits and misses, but I always feel such joy when someone starts asking me questions, because they see that I live a life a little different then them. The biggest impression, at the start, is that I go to church every Sunday. There is another woman, at work, who seemed spiritually stressed and confided in me and wanted to discuss about God. I said a few simple words and she was interested in talking about it more. I lent her some old periodicals from Orthodox Living and a small excerpt about the Holy Light. I only repeated things that I read from the holy fathers. I read alot, for myself and no non-Orthodox writer could every instill the truth in my heart, that really matters, about the faith. I’m also talking to someone else who is struggling to learn the truth of God. I do what I can. I am thankful, to God, that He chooses to use me as a tool for their salvation. I don’t stand on a soap box, like the Protestants, though. Maybe that’s why it’s not so obvious, out there.

The reason I’m saying this is that there is alot more going on out there. It may not look like anything is happening, but it is. It’s just that the heteric Christians have more power, because they are accepted by the world. I don’t see Orthodox books in regular bookstores, only in stores that are religious and even then, they have a small section as compared to the papists and other religions. The only way to get a big selection is to buy from online Orthodox websites.

They're too busy fighting among themselves as to who is and who is not Orthodox -- church politics.

This is an internal battle, for sure. And the main cause is ecumenism. Plus, ecumenism is so strong because it is the way of the world.

It is evangelical and protestants scholars and theologians who are on the forefront in combating our culture and the ungodly teachings of the world.

They aren’t combating it...they are sugar-coating it. There’s a difference. That’s because they are also leading the people to ecumenism. If these scholars and theologians were true believers of Christ, then wouldn’t they have discovered Orthodoxy? Their knowledge is greatly flawed until they accept true theology which is not just a teaching but a way of life. Many Orthodox “theologians” have fallen into the secular scholastic circle of worldly acceptance too.

The identity of Christ is under attack today by Gnostics, Mason's Jews and atheists. Are you even aware of this?

Evfimy, I don’t appreciate your tone. Yes. I am FULLY aware of their attacks. And the protestants and the papists and the evangalists.

The protestants and evangelical scholars have pulverized their arguments.

You are obviously not aware of the game plan.

You haven't even read the books I listed and you draw conclusions prior to examination.

Because I know their game plan. It’s a waste of money and time to read their books.

I was selective in my bibliograohy. Nothing they say contradicts what we Orthodox hold to be true: God exists, Jesus is God, Jesus rose from the dead in His own body.

Since they are non-Orthodox, then don’t you think that they will have an underlying mis-conception of the spiritual depth of Christ; subtle to those who are well-read in Orthodox doctrine and theology by the holy fathers, but un-noticable to those who consider these protestant writers as actually having some view that matters. It’s a ruse.

Even a broken clock is right twice a day. We should be thankful God is using them.

That is a good analogy. It gives us a specific view that they are wrong 92% of the time. I don’t see God as using them to bring others to the truth. They care more about making money and mis-leading the blind. If anything, alot of protestant converts come to Orthodoxy because they are dis-illusioned by the protestant self-illumination. And their theology is completely wrong. Even their view of Jesus Christ is not expressed in truth as held by Apostolic succession. I would not recommend non-Orthodox books to someone who wants to convert to Orthodoxy.

The truths in heterodoxy is the Orthodoxy they have retained. They are ultimately our truths.

They are a complete distortion and a dead faith. Living in Christ can only be experienced in Orthodoxy when living in the true faith. If your kids wanted to eat only McDonalds every single day, breakfast, lunch and supper, would you appreciate the fact that they are eating or would you see, with logic, that you are killng their bodies faster than they are growing?

And I know from experience in debating atheists and people of other religions, that the material in the books I listed is irrefutable.

How many converted to Orthodoxy?

And the material in those books come from some of the worlds greatest scholars and experts.

Of the world, not of God. If they are such experts, then have they converted to Orthodoxy? If they are such great experts, then did they realize what is the full truth, with their great expertise? How can they miss something so obvious, since they see it with such expertise?

I've heard these arguements many times. They don't float.

Create in me a clean heart, O God, and renew a right spirit within me. (Ps. 50)

Evfimy

Post by Evfimy »

There is a story in the New Testament where a man was casting out demons in Jesus name, but he did not follow the band of apostles and Christ. The apostles forbad him since he did not follow their own band. Jesus told them to forbid him not; for no one could do a miracle in Jesus' name that can lightly speak evil of Him (Mark.9:38-39). In other words, God was working with that man not because he was an apostle but in spite of it.

"For he that is not against us is on our part" (Mark 9:40).

God often uses people the most who would otherwise be the least likely. And He uses the humble to confound the wise.

World famous atheist philosopher, Anthony Flew has recently renounced atheism. Not because the Orthodox were pursuading and working on him, but because evangelical theologian Gary Habermas was. Granted, Flew is not yet Orthodox, but he has taken a major step-closer.

If you could refer me to any Orthodox apologetic material refuting the current attacks of our culture on the faith, let me know. All I know of is the book by Andreyev (Orthodox Apologetic Theology), but is not detalied enough and is very shallow.

When I was a teenager my faith was week at times. It was because of the orthodoxy (small "o")in one protestanst theologian, Walter Martin, that taught me the need for sound orthodox faith. This orthodoxy eventually led me to Orthodox Christianity.

So we never know what God might be doing with people and who He might be using.

I rather have people be evangelical, protestanst, or Roman Catholic, than Gnostics, Mason's or atheists.

The books I recommended do not push faith. They push TRUTHS. The truths of the existence of God, the deity of Christ and His resurrection from the dead.

Some of the Father's in Saint Gregory Palamas Monastery in Etna, attended non-Orthodox theological schools. One of them even told me once that protestant scholarship could be good scholarship.

I would agree with you if the books I gave were pusing heretical dogma's. But they aren't. They are pushing TRUTHS of the faith. There's a difference.

User avatar
joasia
Protoposter
Posts: 1858
Joined: Tue 29 June 2004 7:19 pm
Jurisdiction: RTOC
Location: Montreal

Post by joasia »

When I was a teenager my faith was week at times. It was because of the orthodoxy (small "o")in one protestanst theologian, Walter Martin, that taught me the need for sound orthodox faith. This orthodoxy eventually led me to Orthodox Christianity.

Can you elaborate on this? First of all, I don't know if you are cradle or convert. If you want to make your point, then it would be appropriate to specify your background.

What specific teaching grabbed you?

Create in me a clean heart, O God, and renew a right spirit within me. (Ps. 50)

User avatar
joasia
Protoposter
Posts: 1858
Joined: Tue 29 June 2004 7:19 pm
Jurisdiction: RTOC
Location: Montreal

Post by joasia »

There is a story in the New Testament where a man was casting out demons in Jesus name, but he did not follow the band of apostles and Christ. The apostles forbad him since he did not follow their own band. Jesus told them to forbid him not; for no one could do a miracle in Jesus' name that can lightly speak evil of Him (Mark.9:38-39). In other words, God was working with that man not because he was an apostle but in spite of it.

And so, you are comparing the time when Jesus walked the earth to now? Could it be possible, that Jesus was speaking in the context of the situation at hand? Perhaps, He was saying...I am here, let the work be done. Or are we to use His statement to accept all non-Orthodox activities that profess His name, 2000 years later?

This man, in the Bible, that used His name, for his commercial benefit..he performed miracles. True miracles. The protestants and evangalists that do their performances...do they perform miracles? True miracles?

So, basically, you are promoting ecumenism, right? You believe that miracles and the Holy Spirit work outside of the True Church of Christ...Orthodoxy. Other Christian denominations have every authority to Christ, in their spiritual expressions. Because, the passage you pick is typical of a protestant arguement.

Create in me a clean heart, O God, and renew a right spirit within me. (Ps. 50)

Evfimy

Post by Evfimy »

joasia wrote:

Can you elaborate on this? First of all, I don't know if you are cradle or convert. If you want to make your point, then it would be appropriate to specify your background.

What specific teaching grabbed you?

All are converts (hopefully). You can be baptised, christmated, tonsured and ordained to the hierarchy and still never know Christ. Conversion occurs in the heart, not the body. Baptism does not make a person a child of God.

"God is able of these stones to raise up children unto Abraham" (John the Baptist).

One is not a Jew who is one outwardly, but one inwardly, through the circumcision of the heart (Saint Paul).

Being born in an Orthodox or Jewish family does not afford anyone any special priviledges with God. Conversion is an internal thing that we all must consciously decide to do.

When I was a teenager (pentecostal), Baptist minister, Walter Martin showed me the need for correct doctrine. He strongly pushed the importance of maintaining what he would call the essentials of the faith(deity of Christ, resurrection, virgin birth, etc).

I just carried his position to its logical conclusion and joined the Orthodox Church. The nature of the Church is also an essential of the faith. For some reason people like Martin never saw this.

Evfimy

Post by Evfimy »

I do not promote ecumenism, and I do not say sacramental grace exists outside the Orthodox Church. But God's grace is with all people to some extent. God's grace moved me and you to join the flock of His true sheep in Orthodoxy. God's grace moved Saint Paul from persecuter of the faith, to martyr for the faith.

I don't put God in a little box like Gregory of Colorado.

God can do whatever He wants. And the true light lights every man that comes into the world (John 1:9). Not just Orthodox Christians.

Post Reply