If Fr. Seraphim Rose could respond to your poll, he could probably only choose item 4 even though he was Orthodox for many years--although not baptized Orthodox.
How Many Here are Orthodox Christians?
OrthodoxyOrDeath wrote:Not baptized Orthodox?? If by this you mean he was received by economia, then yes. But in no way was he Baptized by the Church while outside the Chruch.
And like I wrote, he could only choose option 4, right? Options 5-8 have "baptized" as a stipulation, which in your judgement he was not. I guess you would say that Fr. Seraphim was not a baptized Christian?
-
- Newbie
- Posts: 37
- Joined: Sun 29 December 2002 12:06 am
- Location: Stratford, CT USA
- Contact:
Not a judgement, just a category
Dear.... can I call you something OTHER than Moronikos?
YOu wrote:
And like I wrote, he could only choose option 4, right? Options 5-8 have "baptized" as a stipulation, which in your judgement he was not.<
It's not a judgement; it's a category. Some people are scrupulous, and if I only said "Baptised Orthodox for X years," they wouldn't have a place to vote. I could just have said "received." But it's also interesting to note how people came to Orthodoxy, or even if they've come yet or not.